People only comment when they like a photo OR what you have done with it.... Im loving being praised, But at the same time, how am supposed to improve my photography when Im not being informed when im making editing stuffups.... What looks ok to me, is most likely not going to be approved by others. I would love the whole constructive criticism AND Hints and ideas to help me improve myself and my photos... Any one who has a chance to help out, please do so, OR if any one else wants to join my queue of requesting our work to be graded, sign on up below and maybe some people will be nice enough to help us out!
When I look at the posts I do comment on what I like, and not being a professional photographer myself, rather doing it for pure enjoyment like most on here. I lack many of the insightful skills of the trade, though there are times when I think that perhaps the lighting could be different, or perhaps a different angle would work more to the photogrpaher's advantage I might add a comment / suggestion or two. Generally speaking though, I think most of us on here are a little leary to say much in re" to the photographer's approach. If I am asked specifically I will take a good look at the photo and give some feedback.
@kick_the_cow The problem is its hard to know who wants their work critisised and who doesn't so I tend to comment more on the work that I like. You may find you get a response more to your liking if you put "Critique" in your tags, then at least people will know that you are looking for constructive critisism :)
A lot of people give reasons why they don't like to give criticism. I for one, am not a professional so I feel I have no business telling people how to change things. I know what I like and those are the ones I comment on. I have noticed people post threads looking for people to make their way over to their projects and to provide some constructive criticism. Hope the link above gives you some answers and maybe a few people who are willing to give you what you need.
Now thats an Idea @ lee gordon.... thanks, that never occured to me....
And @ rick, You always say such beautifull things about my photos and I really do appreciate it ALOT... But sometimes I feel that that things dont recieve a comment are because I have totally messede it up... Or am I being my usual paranoid self... OOOHHH, theres a photo idea!!
isnt it funny how people are so cautious about offending people the dont know and will probably never meet...... Just observing that there is still humanity somewhere, but not where i expected to find it, the internet of all places.
There`s a "critique me" tag for that.
I feel the same about the comments allways being too "good",but I`m okay with the positive overflow,because I know what I`m doing wrong,I`m my own worst critic.
All I need is to browse around here or on FlickR and check out some pro`s and I instantly realise what/how I do wrong,what my photos lack and what needs improving.
I suck at it,and untill I become more self-confident,untill I can look at the majority of my shots and be proud,I won`t ask for criticism.
But it should be understandable that I do welcome critique all the time,and I would never feel offended for people doing so.
And I do think the biggest part of this critiquing issue is that most of us are here to have fun, and primarily for personal enjoyment. Let's not forget about the friendship aspect of this fine community. Though a critque may be done in a "constructive" way, and in no way meant to "hurt" anyone's feelings, some individuals may actaully perceive a "critique" in the wrong sense. In that case, for the person who is here primarily for the joy of photography, sharing photos with others, and creating a year long journal / album of their life, the critique may have just created a sense of or a feeling of inferiority. The result may be a hesitancy to coninue in that original desire to have fun, because now they feel as though they must meet certain criteria. That kind of pressure can take away from the joy, part of what this project is all about. I am not saying that we are a critical bunch, far from it. This is such a great group of folks, and most are very supportive and caring. You know how we can be though. Sometimes, depending on what is happening in our lives, as we look at some of the great photos and the awesome talent that shows up here, we might unconsciously begin to evaluate and unfairly compare ourselves to their work, and then come to the conclusion, I am out of place here, which would be a shame. That is not what this is about. I think if someone wants to get some good constructive feedback, use the "critique" button as suggested or just ask. Most will give it a good try and offer feedback.
@kick_the_cow , @digitalrn . i agree with you Rick . personally I dont care one way or the other if people think my photos are crap or not,, most of the time they are..
although most of the time they are funny.. they will never make me millions..
But thats not why Im here... as you mentioned this is a fun project for me. and if someone was to come along and say hey you could have done AB and C I'd be sitting there saying to myself,, ok who cares? I didnt take the photo because of that reason,, I took it for XYZ reason and thats enough for me... I guess part of it for me is a confidence that I have , that my photo is good enough for me and thats all that matters..
and yeah if the time comes when I need advice I will ask for it..
I love all the comments I get from the people that follow me.. but they are commenting on the situation of the photo and having a laugh not the technicals of the photo and I love that!!!
I feel a lot of people on here are of the same opinion , they are here to have fun with their project, improve a little and make some connections with other people who feel the same...
and personally if EVERY photo I put on here was subject to critique I would not be posting ......
@sallycheese I feel the same way. I don't seem to get much response on my photo's, it makes me feel like I just suck at this. Maybe I do, who knows, cause I tried the critique me tag, and only got one bite. I comment/follow lots of people. Still not much. I truly feel discouraged and totally uninteresting. Its kinda sad, but I just keep telling myself this is for me, and if I like them, its fine, its my project afterall. It still kinda stinks when im proud of a shot, and not one person notices it.
@staciehighland@sallycheese --- With thousands of people posting pictures, it is hard to stand out and build a following. I suggest you participate in the Browse and Pick (currently on 64). This will help people to see your work as well as give you a good indication as to the photos people like and why. You will also see what you like in others pictures.
@sallycheese@staciehighland As Dorrena said, you need to let people know you're here - thousands of photos slip between the cracks because nobody knows the photographer even exists.
@indiannie_jones@dmortega yeah i appreciate that, i try and get involved in the discussions etc so that people see me about, i have felt a bit paranoid as have started a couple of discussions which have had loads of views but about 1 comment lol i know it's just a case of people only answering if they see it or can advise/help and need to get over myself a bit ;)
I think in Photography everything is good. That is depends on a person how he/she will look at it.. Anybody who buys a photo that is for him/her is a good photo may not be good photo for others. It's how you satisfy yourself and not others. It's true that most of here are more on praising photos because they like it and they are being satisfied base on how they feel about it. Most of us here are really not on a professional thing that's why they don't give much critique or even constructive comment because they might lead the persons direction or interest. Lets face it that most of us wants more praises than criticism and deep inside we are affected on negative views whenever we read something.every person has its own sensitive side. Lucky are those brave who can face their mistakes. Remember that no matter how your photo turns out even it's a great one not all would agree that it is really great., simply because we have our own preferences and standards. Just believe in what you have and what you can. Thanks
I've been mindful to only make positive comments on photo's posted on 365 because you really don't know how another photographer will take a "it would be better if you did,,," kind of comment. I get my stuff judged almost weekly in competitions and club meetings, and have seen other club members get really unfair criticism when a judge just doesn't get the point of a photo.
I would be glad to offer ideas on improving photographs, but would need to be sure that it was what the photographer wanted.
I, too, agree with the comments about not asking for criticism. I am doing this project for the challenge and to put a year of my life in photographs. Most of my photographs do not receive comments but that doesn't stop me from posting them. I happen to love what I'm doing, and I love seeing other people have fun with photography.
Write a Reply
Sign up for a free account or Sign in to post a comment.
Tweets ahoy!
Join the Group
Pin With Me
A lot of people give reasons why they don't like to give criticism. I for one, am not a professional so I feel I have no business telling people how to change things. I know what I like and those are the ones I comment on. I have noticed people post threads looking for people to make their way over to their projects and to provide some constructive criticism. Hope the link above gives you some answers and maybe a few people who are willing to give you what you need.
And @ rick, You always say such beautifull things about my photos and I really do appreciate it ALOT... But sometimes I feel that that things dont recieve a comment are because I have totally messede it up... Or am I being my usual paranoid self... OOOHHH, theres a photo idea!!
Otherwise, people hesitate because the project is rather personal to most so an innocent comment can be easily miscontrued.
I feel the same about the comments allways being too "good",but I`m okay with the positive overflow,because I know what I`m doing wrong,I`m my own worst critic.
All I need is to browse around here or on FlickR and check out some pro`s and I instantly realise what/how I do wrong,what my photos lack and what needs improving.
I suck at it,and untill I become more self-confident,untill I can look at the majority of my shots and be proud,I won`t ask for criticism.
But it should be understandable that I do welcome critique all the time,and I would never feel offended for people doing so.
The Mindful Eye - http://www.tmelive.com/
although most of the time they are funny.. they will never make me millions..
But thats not why Im here... as you mentioned this is a fun project for me. and if someone was to come along and say hey you could have done AB and C I'd be sitting there saying to myself,, ok who cares? I didnt take the photo because of that reason,, I took it for XYZ reason and thats enough for me... I guess part of it for me is a confidence that I have , that my photo is good enough for me and thats all that matters..
and yeah if the time comes when I need advice I will ask for it..
I love all the comments I get from the people that follow me.. but they are commenting on the situation of the photo and having a laugh not the technicals of the photo and I love that!!!
I feel a lot of people on here are of the same opinion , they are here to have fun with their project, improve a little and make some connections with other people who feel the same...
and personally if EVERY photo I put on here was subject to critique I would not be posting ......
I would be glad to offer ideas on improving photographs, but would need to be sure that it was what the photographer wanted.