Same Apple.......Different Egg

I had an idea as a follow up to a recent photo of the apple and the egg. While I was getting it set up it occured to me the halfway execution would also make an interesting photo. This is the halfway execution. What do you think?

[Lou Ann]

So different looking now, the tone and colors and mood of the image are moody, to me. A good interpretation of halves.

[Hope D Jennings]

Wonderfully lit. Love the comp

[KoalaGardens🐨]

so good

[Diana]

Another great shot Katy, I prefer the other version though ;-)

[Geertje K.]

I think this is also fun, but I like the other version better. That one has better composition and a more arty feel, I think

[Leslie]

I don't know why my mind sees a little dinosaur popping out of that egg....lol

[Lin]

Awesome - you really have the creativity flowing this year!!!

[Bep]

Both pictures are beautiful, but I like the other version better.

[Nicole Campbell]

I think you have created a wonderful minimalist image.

[Ann H. LeFevre]

I like it- very artsy!

[Kathy]

I like how the shell is balanced on the apple.

[katy]

@louannwarren @mzzhope @koalagardens @ludwigsdiana @geertje @lesip @linnypinny @gijsje @nicolecampbell @olivetreeann @randystreat I really appreciate your comments and have to agree with you about the other one being better. Initially I thought this one was but now, not so much. Although it looks a little like a composite the egg is really balanced on the apple and I was a little concerned about it staying for the shot!
It would have been a great mess if it hadn't! LOL! Leslie I will try to remember that for another time!

[Jacqueline]

Almost missed this one. Very creative idea and shot!

[katy]

@jacqbb Are far too generous with your praise! Thanks though!