Sunset at Cleawox single shot

My mentoring group has a challenge this month with "natural" HDR. I am uploading three different edits of this lovely sunset that we had last night just for comparison. This one wasthe darkest of three bracketted images edited in LR. I'll be curious to see which of the three you like the best.
Thanks for your visits, comments, suggestions, favs and for taking my little pigeon guillemot shot to the PP yesterday.

[Beth Sheppard]

I like this one best, though the one with all three shots is nice too.

[Jane Pittenger]

@taffy @golftragic @pamknowler @888rachel @newbank Here are my first natural HDR attempts for our theme

[Taffy]

Jane, what a beauty. I'm off to look at the three of them and then will comment.

[Taffy]

Okay -- to me, this looks the most natural but I am drawn to the increased details in the middle version. The lightest one is my least favorite. But what a scene!

[Graham Thresher]

Fabulous shot. Fav

[Graeme Stevens]

superb shot

[Judith Johnson]

Wow - gorgeous deep colour and stillness.

[Debra]

Stunning! Fav!

[sally agnew]

Beautiful serene waters, love the colours :)

[Steve Angell]

Lovely shot Jane. This is my favourite.

[Lisa Malecki]

fav

[Shari]

I like this one.

[Luretta]

Awesome light and reflection. Really, really beautiful.

[Marnie]

My #1 vote is for this one Jane. It combines the best of the lights and darks very well and the darker lighting plays down the straight lines of what looks like concrete structures. Vote 2 for the middle image.

[Jennifer]

gorgeous - this one is my favourite. fav

[Rachel]

I like this one the best out of the 3 shots. The colours are the most vibrant and I like the contrast with the dark silhouettes.

[Lindy]

Spectacular sunset capture.