I have passed this a 100 times and finally pulled in to get some shots on Christmas day. Here I am processing another shot in Silver Efex and this time I used the full spectrum filter. Then I used a control point over the people at the end to make them more visible. Brought the software today with my bonus morning and a little cash of my own.
@northy Less noise, then in lr I adjusted the white and black point, lens, and added a very slight vignette- darker around the edge put not outstanding.
@northy@joansmor Some of the filters in the Efex suite duplicate what we would normally do in LR - open up the shadows, reduce the highlights, increase midrange contrast, etc - and these introduce noise. If we make these adjustments in LR first we end up with noise on noise so I only adjust in LR at the end if I think more work is needed, it seldom is.
@vignouse ah... ok... well - my workflow does involve making those sorts of adjustments in LR, but i think i'm generally making adjustments in LR mindful of what i am intending to do in nik silver fx... i really actually want to get to a place where i can reproduce the nik silver fx in LR... i actually only do basic conversion in silver fx... all tweaking of whites and blacks, vignettes and control point work i do in LR...
@northy We're on the same lines: if you remember my original comment, my workflow for a B&W conversion is to correct perspective, make any crop that might be nenecessary and then make a virtual copy. I carry on with the conversion in LR and when I've finished, I export the virtual copy to Silver Efex and make another conversion there. When I've finished, I compare the two: suprisingly often - about 50% of the time I would say - I take the LR conversion.
@vignouse@northy I got the silver efex because I want some of the look I see in both your bw's with my subjects. Silver efex will allow me that while I learn to control more in LR.
so how did you find doing the work in silver fx first?
Very romantic, good depth and I like it when a picture tells a story. FAV
I'm tempted by silver Efex, assume you'd recommend it?
I see that you really enjoy your B&W editing.