Broken Lens - New vs Repair

September 25th, 2021
I dropped my Nikon Tamron 18-400 lens and sent it in for repair. I thought I had an extended warranty but apparently the Tamron warranty was only for 6 months and the camera shop where I purchased it closed so I am unable to verify if there actually was any extended warranty. (I can't find anything other than my bill of sale.) Repair info says shock damage, zoom damage and internal cam barrel bent or cracked. I purchased it for about $650 in Jul 2020 and the repairs would be close to $400. My question: Am I better off purchasing a new lens rather than paying for the repair? Thoughts?
September 25th, 2021
Sorry to hear that. 😟 Assuming you couldn't claim on insurance - based on your calculations, personally I wouldn’t bother with the repair.. 😬
September 25th, 2021
@genealogygenie I accidently dropped a camera with a lens on it and could claim on my house & contents insurance for replacements of both. Would that be an option?
September 25th, 2021
With insurance, I think you need to consider two factors; firstly the excess that you have to pay and secondly if you claim on insurance, you are likely to be faced with an increased insurance premium for at least three years.

Considering the value of the lens I would write it off and buy either a new one or a second hand one, preferably from a reputable source.
September 25th, 2021
Bummer! If you are open to used lenses, there is always ebay or KEH ( https://www.keh.com/shop/nikon-nikkor-80-400mm-f-4-5-5-6d-ed-vr-af-telephoto-zoom-lens.html ). I've bought several items from them and have found their service and quality wonderful.
September 25th, 2021
So sorry to hear about your lens! Sad to say but it is probably better to get a new one if you can't use a warranty or insurance. However, you may find for just a little bit more than the repair you can get a better one/new one. If you don't want to spend that much, like Joy says, there are several ways to buy used lenses that are still in perfect shape for a lot less than new. That's how I ended up with my zoom and wide angle lenses.
September 28th, 2021
@brigette @nickspicsnz @lumpiniman @joysabin @olivetreeann Thank you each for your comments. I went with the new lens.
Write a Reply
Sign up for a free account or Sign in to post a comment.