Which one to choose by mave

Which one to choose

I need a black and white picture for our camera club Zoom meeting, and I am torn between these two. Looking for your opinion.
Easy choice for me the top one. I think its a far more powerful with the silhouetted people. Fav for the top one!
October 18th, 2020  
I agree with @rjb71 , wonderful composition of the silhouette of two men giving it quite a 3D effect !
October 18th, 2020  
Bep
Top one!
October 18th, 2020  
I like both of them and it would be very hard to pick. I guess I would lean towards the top one, too.
October 18th, 2020  
Super b&w images
October 18th, 2020  
Difficult to choose but I think the top one is very good because it has added interest with the two men fishing. My next U3A meeting is B/W too.Fav
October 18th, 2020  
@rjb71 @beryl @gijsje Thank you. I was leaning to the top one too.
@mittens @seattlite @wendyfrost Thanks for helping me.
I keep trying to get a mono landscape but I don't think I have the right one yet.
October 18th, 2020  
Oh for me the top one but I like a people shot so biased!
October 18th, 2020  
These are both great but the top one nudges it for me too
October 18th, 2020  
I like both, but would imagine the camera club might prefer the shot with silhouettes.
October 18th, 2020  
I like the top one but it feels like it needs a nudge of straightening?
October 18th, 2020  
@koalagardens You are right. I hadn't noticed. Points off for me.
October 18th, 2020  
Top one for me. Love the guy sitting on the wall.
October 18th, 2020  
Top one for me too, it tells a story.

The bottom one is nice but it looks a bit chopped off the way it is cropped.
October 18th, 2020  
Top one...great silhouettes
October 19th, 2020  
Top one, Mave.
October 19th, 2020  
Love the top one Mave with the wonderful silhouettes.
October 19th, 2020  
Leave a Comment
Sign up for a free account or Sign in to post a comment.