Shadows from incorrect lighting

June 16th, 2011
Here are two photos I took that have been critiqued for harsh shadows (thanks, btw). I know my lighting is incorrect. My question is, I suppose, is whether or not I should have edited the shadows out or not? My friend loved the pic of her so I'm not sure if a non-photographer eye would be bothered by this.

Also, I have been told to point my speedlite up or behind to bounce the light to get rid of shadows but I don't have white walls and high ceilings in most areas, or I'm outside. What do I do then?

Thanks for your help!

June 16th, 2011
Regarding the bottom photo; have your tried post-editing the shadows out? There aren't many and the ones under the arm are not distracting at all. With the top the shadow is very prominent and the lines in the corner of the back wall is distracting. This could be easily fixed in photo shop with a totally different background. It's a great shot.
June 16th, 2011
@dmortega No I haven't tried. I just got PS elements and I'm a bit overwhelmed.
June 16th, 2011
There are lots of tutorials online. Now is the time to play around with these pictures to see what you can do. Let us know what you come up with. :-)
June 16th, 2011
you want to look into flash diffusers



and flash reflectors





diffusers lessen the harshness of the light and reflectors bounce the light. it is possible to make home made diffusers and reflectors and there are instructions online, but they are pretty cheap to buy anyway
June 17th, 2011
@asrai Duh...I knew that just totally forgot. Thanks!
June 17th, 2011
@dmortega @asrai A few tutorials and here it is. What do you think now?
Except now I want to clone out the wall edges, LOL!
June 17th, 2011
@arrayofblues well done :D
June 17th, 2011
Way better. Take a look under the arm that is down and if you can clone out the lines in the wall, this will be even better. You are on the right track. :-)
June 17th, 2011
The further your subject is from the background, the less obvious shadows will be. High ceilings don't matter for bounce - just increase your flash output, and maybe your ISO. Coloured ceilings however.....

You can also bounce off a handheld reflector (you'll need someone or something to hold it).

I don't use on-camera diffusers. Tried them, hate them. I think Gary Fong is a brilliant marketer of stuff people don't need.

On the subject of bad shadowing, it's interesting to see that some pro photographers just don't seem to care, as can be seen in this advertising photo of Dakota Fanning: http://dolly.ninemsn.com.au/tags.aspx?domain=site&tags=perfumes|Themes and larger version here: http://www.bellasdiary.com/2011/03/dakota-fanning-for-march-jacobs-perfume-oh-lola/

Of course, I think that photo is absolute rubbish. I'm sure the photographer still made a fortune from it though.
Write a Reply
Sign up for a free account or Sign in to post a comment.