Rawcomp 11

January 13th, 2014
Here is the link to the raw file for this competition:

https://www.dropbox.com/s/s1agaz181pclxd9/DW048369.dng

And here is an unedited SOOC version (Don't download from this page - download from the dropbox link above):



A reminder of the rules.

"All editing must be done with a RAW processor, using no other software or plugins" - so either Lightroom, Adobe Camera RAW, the RAW processing software that came with your camera, but nothing else that does more than RAW processing - no NIK plugins, no compositions, no other editing other than RAW processing. This differentiates it from WWYD, where any editing goes"

Make sure your photo is tagged rawcomp11

Entries must be submitted by Midnight Friday (British Time), and voting will happen over the weekend. The winner will be announced some time Monday Morning British Time. Enjoy.
January 13th, 2014
Here is my entry
January 13th, 2014
@iwatts That's fabulous! I think we have our first finalist.
January 13th, 2014
Here's mine. An awkward image as shot. Like Ian, I went for the black and white.

January 14th, 2014
@frankhymus nice entry Frank. Agreed, awkward as shot, needs a crop to trim the overpowering hedges on the right. Bonus points for retaining as much of them as possible.
January 14th, 2014
@frankhymus Why is there such a difference in the vignette effect? Is there something in your RAW processor to clear that, or something in Ian's that brought it out?
January 14th, 2014
I sure don't know what I'm doing. It looks very different on my computer when editing than it does once it's uploaded. I was trying for "natural"...the color of a clear sunny afternoon.
January 14th, 2014
@houser934 I like your version, it is natural. This site does some strange conversion to images when it creates the different sizes. If you include a link to the original upload others can see the colors you have on your monitor. If you need help adding the link, let me know.
January 14th, 2014
So, just because...I tried another version bringing out the yellow to make it a "sunset" shot. This was fun. I am beginning to see what the RAW editor can do.
January 14th, 2014
@houser934 I just treated it as an extended "spot" and removed the vignette in the top right with the extended spot capability of ACR 8.3. There didn't seem to be any left in the other positions after I got through with it. In the Lens Correction panel of ACR there is a vignette editor. Also a "post crop" vignette control in the Effects tab that works well too, vignetting for the crop. But I didn't use any of those since the effect in the image is very asymmetric.
January 14th, 2014
Finally I have time to play. This is so fun Ian what a great idea, thanks for starting this challenge!!

January 14th, 2014
ok my first time here, after looking thru the other entries is cropping not acceptable?
January 14th, 2014
@acloserlookpbd cropping is ok, but I am giving preference to entries that manage to deal with the bushes on the right without completely removing them. The main idea of this challenge is to extract detail and color from the image. Explore the graduated filters and the highlights and shadows sliders.
January 15th, 2014
For the painters

January 16th, 2014
@mikegifford very interesting take on the image!
January 16th, 2014
Anyone lend a hand (or some info) on why I can't open the dng file in ps raw via bridge?
January 16th, 2014
@lisatown what version of ps do you have? The picture was taken with a Pentax K-5, which is a three years old, so I assume you are more up to date than that, but have you updated recently to get the latest camera profiles? Try downloading the file again, it might be corrupt.
January 16th, 2014
Thanks for the reply Daniel. I have an older version PS3. I wonder if that's the problem? I haven't done any investigating online yet... Just thought someone here might have a quick fix for me.
January 16th, 2014
@danielwsc
I've uploaded my effort to my page with the tag rawcomp11. Do I need to do anything else to bring it to your attention or post it here. If so how do I do it? In case you can't tell I'm new to this. :)
January 16th, 2014
@lisatown Hi Lisa. That is a fairly old version of PS. I saved the raw file using a new-ish feature of DNGs, lossy compression. I think if you get the latest version of Camera Raw you should be able to open it. Although Adobe might not support PS3 any more.

Have you thought about Adobe CC for Photographers? $10 / month gets you the latest version of PS and LR, for as long as you keep up the subscription. You still qualify for the special offer (it's normally $20 / month) because you have a PS3 license.
January 16th, 2014
@jfrancis6 Hi Jesse, thanks for participating! You don't need to do anything else, I found your entry (which is darn good btw!) by clicking on the tag. If you want to post your image in this discussion, copy and paste the share code under the tags. It starts with
January 17th, 2014
January 17th, 2014
Got it! Thanks Daniel.
January 17th, 2014
Here is my edit for the challenge. I consider myself as a amateur and all the editing I did was done in Lightroom 5

January 17th, 2014

I don't know if it's allowed but I thought I'd post a different version. This one I did in Lightroom. The other one I did was in Adobe Camera Raw.
Write a Reply
Sign up for a free account or Sign in to post a comment.