Which Should We Open

My get-pushed partner this week was Laura
@la_photographic. The challenge she gave me was: " to take 5 objects and make a still-life of them"
I tried these two arrangements Gail prefers one of them and I prefer the other so I am posting them both. For other photo http://365project.org/hjbenson/365/2014-11-26

[Harry J Benson]

Laura @la_photographic.My next attempt at the challenge

[Kerri]

Awesome shot

[Taffy]

Oh -- I do like this composition a little more than the other.

[Mannie]

Symmetry is also in play here. I don't know if I'm siding with you or Gail, but I like this one better. It's like the bottles are being offered to you.