Lily or Amaryllis? by salza

Lily or Amaryllis?

This flower has appeared in the garden. In 2011 a similar flower bloomed, nothing has bloomed in between, although the green strappy leaves have never died back. I have no idea what it is. Some people say it's an Amaryllis, others say it's a lily!

Here is a link to the picture of the last time it flowered - http://365project.org/salza/365/2011-11-19

Alternate capture: http://365project.org/salza/extras/2015-11-08
Maybe a hybrid? As in the bees cross pollinated two flowers in your garden? It certainly has a curious history! And it's a stunning color as well. Nice shot.
November 8th, 2015  
Beautiful...like your focus and dof.
November 8th, 2015  
Gorgeous whatever it is!! Fav!
November 8th, 2015  
Gorgeous shot, composition, perspective
November 8th, 2015  
Beautiful capture of this flower. I'd say amaryllis, but what do I know?!
November 8th, 2015  
Lovely! Not sure what it is, but like the form/color that you emphasize in creating the composition.
November 8th, 2015  
Wow ... apart from anything else it shows the vast improvement in your photographic style!
November 8th, 2015  
❤❤❤
November 8th, 2015  
A beautiful bloom, beautifully photographed against a complimentary background.
November 8th, 2015  
Ah beautiful and so different.
November 9th, 2015  
Beautiful image
November 9th, 2015  
I am not sure which it is! But it's a beauty, fabulous shot.
November 9th, 2015  
Stunning, love the pop of red against the gray background Sally!
Sorry I can't help you, not sure what it is.
November 9th, 2015  
Yes. Stunning!
November 9th, 2015  
Excellent. A fav
November 9th, 2015  
Beautiful capture whichever it is. Back in our RAF days one of our neighbours called her daughter Amaryllis I often wonder how she coped with it when she grew up. I can't help feeling that she would have preferred Lily, ha ha.
November 9th, 2015  
@onewing I think I would have changed my name! In South Africa she'd probably get the nickname 'Blom', which is Afrikaans for flower.
November 9th, 2015  
Amaryllis are cultivars of Hippeastrums but are known by names such as belladonna lily - I have never known either to keep leaves though - it looks like one of my hippeastrums
November 10th, 2015  
@annied Annie this is exactly what my research has shown. When it last flowered in 2011, I emailed two different garden magazines. Both were adamant that it is an amaryllis and never responded when I questioned the leaves. The leaves grow just like clivias, which is what I thought the plant was until it flowered. I think I will send pictures again and see if anyone comes up with a bright idea.
November 10th, 2015  
@salza let me know if you get an answer I am very curious because of the leaves and the intermittent flowering :)
November 10th, 2015  
@annied I will do just that!
November 10th, 2015  
Gorgeous close up. Love the colour.
November 13th, 2015  
Leave a Comment
Sign up for a free account or Sign in to post a comment.