Was he right??

I took several photo's on the 17th, my husband said he liked this one best, was he right?The one that I thought best & put on365 on the 17th. went on the pp page which I was thrilled about. Thank you for all the fave's and comments

[Kerri]

So beautiful

[Roberta Clark Chalmers]

They both are wonderful. This one offers a broader sweep to the horizon and sky while still having that great gnarly tree as the focal point. I think I agree with your husband but it is a difficult choice. I'll fav this one too!

[Lara Zinn]

I guess it depends on what is more appealing to the viewer... here you can have a better view of the animal in the background, but on the other one the portrait choice makes the silhoette of the tree breathtaking. I prefer the other one, but I love this one well, so I am faving it too.

[Melody Hartwell]

Sorry- I don't care for this one at all, the best part of the tree is missing. I've gone back & faved the !st one( some how I missed it before)

[judith deacon]

Both fabulous but I think I prefer this one because you can see more of the overall scene and the animals in the foreground, but both are terrific and both are Faves in my opinion!

[Bronwen]

It's lovely too but I think you were right - the other photo shows more of the gnarly branches of the tree, which I think is why it's so appealing.

[Julie Ryan]

I like the other one better, but this one is great too!! I used it for my wallpaper for a couple of days on my computer.

[Pat Knowles]

They are both gorgeous & you know the other went down really well but personally I like this one...but then I would wouldn't I , it has cows on it !!!

[Diana Moss]

@happypat Thank you for your comment Pat, if you look close you will see the other pic. had cows around the tree.

[Amber D]

I think this is lovely, Diana. He did good. :0)

[Karen Sylvia]

It's a tough choice, but I like this one just a little more.

[karenann]

Hard to decide between two beautiful photos like this. When my husband selects his favorite photo, he's usually right. Both of yours have the beautiful silhouette . . and are gorgeous pastoral compositions. You can't lose either way. :)

[Judith Greenwood]

Hmmm - I like the off-centre tree and it is gorgeous but I like your first choice - that tree is absolutely stunning in all its glory.

[Elizabeth Hanna]

I love this one .... your eye is drawn into the depth of the scene because of the asymmetrical arrangement. It is just beautiful.

[Diana Moss]

@elizabeth Thank you for your comment

[Rick Schies]

Well I always enjoy tree photos, and the silhouette here is quite nice Diana.

[Netkonnexion]

Great shot, but I liked the other one better.

[alia_801]

This is a cool shot too :) Love the mistiness and the cows :)

[Di O'Donovan]

So beautiful

[Beth]

Yup, agree with hubby. Love this one.

[Isla Wight]

Oh like this one too - can't decide - v. dramatic.

[FaerieMoon]

I love them both--the one on the 17th shows off the branches more but this one has a really nice composition.

[Helen Moss]

Sorry Dad, got to agree with Mum on this one - I like the other one better!

[Cynthia]

Beautiful! I love the sharpness you were able to capture between the tree and the sky.

[Pam Womack]

love this silhouette