Processing critique requested

June 29th, 2012


Working mainly from this tutorial: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UcYB3T5w61s&feature=related

and with this SOOC image: http://www.flickr.com/photos/alpeedee/7465826526/in/photostream

I'd appreciate feedback on my processing. (I know I missed the 2nd eye, in terms of the actual shot itself, with having his face slightly angled and such a shallow dof.)
Processing:
As above steps in youtube video
Healing brush for last little blotches
Dodge tool on the in focus eye
Unsharp mask on whole image (maybe overdone?)

Does the skin tone look nice and natural to you and not overworked?

(sorry about the links, when I try to format with tags everything disappeard)
June 29th, 2012
Oh, the video is a tutorial on "correcting color with curves and Hue/Saturation".

Take an eyedrop sample, show in CMYK, adjust curves etc.
June 29th, 2012
I really like it. Thanks for the links. It's a shame there is not some way to adjust the 2nd eye... or maybe someone will have an idea of how to do it. So cute :)!!!
June 29th, 2012
The only thing I might add is to brighten it somehow, not so much the background but the subject. I have PSE 10 and some pre-set photoshop actions that would make this look a little fresher. Yes too bad about the eye, this has happened to me plenty of times before. Not really much you can do (that I know of ) to change it.
This is my version using a preset called serendipity from paintthemoon.net
June 29th, 2012
@newbie to me this looks better the skin tone was a little bland before
June 29th, 2012
@alpeedee Here's my take on your processed image. Great job overall. I'd play with contrast a tiny bit. I certainly don't think you over-sharpened and skin tones are very nice on my monitor. Just for fun, I worked on his right eye a bit and played with contrast, then burned the highlights out over his head. Congratulations on a magnificent portrait - Well shot.

June 29th, 2012
@lesphoto What did you do to improve his eye? Looks so much better
June 29th, 2012
@lesphoto what did you do to fix his eye? what a difference it made!
June 29th, 2012
@lesphoto The eye looks great!
June 29th, 2012
@jgpittenger @katiebrenkert I'm using PS - Isolated left eye, copied, moved it over to right eye then kind of tweaked the shape to fit in better with the transform tool (warp). Added a little blur because it was now too sharp a contrast for surrounding area. Then flattened layers.
June 30th, 2012
@newbie I've been using some of the actions sets from coffeeshopblog, especially the "Storybook Vintage" one. Great for lightening, brightening and warming an image, but it's not very precise and sometimes feels like using a sledgehammer to crack a nut.

@lesphoto I never even thought of doing that with the eye! Thank you!
June 30th, 2012
nice fix on the eye, I like the skin tone...very soft and innocent. Is this photo as shot or is it a crop? I'm not a fan of the composition...maybe it's the dead space above his head and his chin too low in the frame. If it is as shot, maybe play around with a different crop? Not a critique...just an observation really...
Write a Reply
Sign up for a free account or Sign in to post a comment.