I think you would have needed to be closer to the reflection and show less of the sides. The wood is so rustic it doesn't look like it would be inside. But you could give that illusion if less of it showed. At least that's what I think. You might be able to play with it and crop to see if it works. It's still a good shot as is though.
@olivetreeann Thanks, Ann! I appreciate your input and agree with you. I think if I could shoot one without having to look up, the angle would be better, too.