Siltcoos Stars, Moon, Venus Reflected 1

I am posting this shot again with three different edits of the moon and venus. If you have time, would you enlarge all three (the others are in todays alternate albums) and vote for your preference? I want to use this photo in an upcoming photography club gallery. Thanks SO MUCH

[Lena]

Fabulous shot! The reflections are amazing, fav!

[Pat Knowles]

There again.......

[Issi Bannerman]

Fabulous shot - all three of them!

[carol white]

Wonderful capture,great reflections!! FAV!!

[virtualbrownie]

Amazing shot - they all look good to me so I cannot really pick between them. Fav

[Gerry]

simply fantastic photo Jane fav

[Eric di Bosco]

Although the moon & reflection is somewhat larger in #2 & 3, it looks more authentic in #1, so my vote goes for #1! But good luck with your choice and entry!

[Kerri]

Beautiful

[Tara]

great blues....wonderful!!

[Judith Greenwood]

Hmm - good question - 1 or 3. 1 if pushed.

[Mary Ann]

Wow! This looks wonderful!
Great contrast & color! FAV!

[Caz]

This one by a hair, it's beautiful, I can only dream about taking photos as wonderful as this ! Fav and good luck with whichever one you choose :)

[Sue Wilde]

So difficult but I think this has it by a star

[Ross Walker]

This one, but it is a close call between 1 and 2. The problem is, we are all looking at different screens, and a print will look different still. You can't go wrong with any of them if you get a quality print.

[Sharon]

So beautiful!!

[Vicki Dixon]

awesome...love the reflection and the depth of it all...fav

[Lisa Stein]

They are all gorgeous! I have a hard time comparing them. I don't think you can go wrong though!

[Judith]

Gorgeous, stunning blue colours.

[Leana Niemand]

Jane, this is quite incredible, wow, what a shot....a big fav!

[Nicole]

beautiful shot! love your work Jane, now following!

[Denise]

Stunning work!!!

[Junan Heath]

Fav! So Lovely! Spectacular photo and wonderful viewed large!

[Teresa]

I agree with Eric, above. At first I was preferring the other two but kept coming back to #1. It feels the sharpest across the photo.

[Dawn Moder]

Lovely!

[Raye]

FAV! I can't get over the mirror smooth water and the reflection!

[Lisa]

I am in total awe, Jane! Love them all. I'll vote for this one , but really wouldn't be able to clearly decide unless I could see them side by side.

[Sandy]

Wow! Great job.

[Jen Hudson]

I think no. 1 is the sharpest too. Hard to choose between 1 and 2. Not 3 I would say. It's a beautiful scene, well captured.

[Paula W]

I think this one has the edge for me too although I couldn't say exactly why. Has to be a fav.