Which lens would you recommend ?

[HD]

1. Tokina 11-16 f/2.8
2. Canon 10-22 f/3.5-4.5
Please paste any photo you have taken using these lenses. Thanks in advance

[Josh Sudweeks]

Why have you ruled out the Sigma 10-20mm f/3.5 or 4.5-5.6?

[HD]

@sudweeks Its too similar to Canon and has mixed reviews. If I was going with a non-canon lens, I would like lot more for the similar price such as fixed aperture and faster lens and hence interest in Tokina.

[ronphotography]

@HD i guess you plan to do landscapes with the mm? i would suggest stick with F/2.8. I just got a Tamron 28-75mm F/2.8, great review, see link:

http://www.tamronlensreview.com/category/review/tamronzoomlens

[Vikdaddy]

Canon is worth paying the premium, in my opinion. 'L' class glass (just about) in an EF-S body.

Here's a few of my shots:

[HD]

@ronphotography Ron, thank you, I will take a look the tamron review too.

[HD]

@vikdaddy Vik, do you ever feel need for wider aperture than f/3.5?
Great photos, I have seen these in your album in the past but didnt realize that it was Canon 10-22. fabulous photos. Thanks for your response.

[Vikdaddy]

@devanago No, never. For landscapes, I wouldn't want to go larger than something like f/8, because I want to keep everything in focus!

[Yousef I]

I have a Sigma 10-20mm f/4-5.6 and you can go through my album
95% of my photos are taken with this lens
its phenomenal!
my favourite lens

I also always shoot at f/8 or smaller as well
I rarely ever go wider

[Wendy]

I also have the Sigma 10-20mm f/4-5.6 lens like @yoshi and love it! Here are a couple of examples with this lens:

[Amy G.]

Go for the 2.8......I couldn't live without it! :)