Wich is my best collage?Please check it out:

[Spaceman]

Could you please chose one,as the best? I`m just curious what you think.Thanks in advance.

1


2


3


4

[KarlaC]

I like 3... It tells more of a story than the others... but they are all great !!!

[Jaydee]

i like them all.... in terms of rendering i love 1, 2 , and 3
but my fave is 1

[taleweaver]

i like 2, i feel like it really tells a story, and it's one i can relate to.
...the same reason @karlacrowney like 3, hehe! it's really interesting to see what appeals to different people :)

[FaerieMoon]

Well, I'll be the dark horse here--I like #4. Personally, I find collages confusing to the eye because there's too much to focus upon, which I why I never do them! #4 seemed the simplest. I do understand about the "story" idea though.

[Emer Hyland]

they are all very interesting in their own right i personally prefare 2 it has anice warm feel to it

[Isabel]

I am a huge fan of collages or mosaics of all types and was happy to have the opportunity to look at yours here. I chose (1). I like the color harmony and the unity of the theme. To my eye the backgrounds of (3) and (4) are a bit too high contrast. Also, for my eye I would slightly adjust the size of the leaf photo in the center of the second bottom row so that the white surrounding is more uniform. That's just my preference though. Very nice work (and yes, if the comments sound like those of a fair judge, that's exactly what I am!)

[Lynn M. Watson]

These are all awesome . . . if I had to pick one it'd be 3, I like the old lady and her slippers :-) but I also like 1, the circles are interesting.

[mullins]

Meh- What a lame effort-dude.This collage thing ain't working out for you. sorry but i'm being objective.LOL..!!!just messing with you Hahaha...All your collages here are piece of ARTWORK...I LOVE 'em all.Each one tells different story-mood-shape-colors and here's my pick..#2 very tranquil and # 3symbolizes time and patience....Keep them coming..:)

[Spaceman]

@dosmanoisabel
Thanks,I really apreciate your criticism,and you are right about the "leaf photo",it is too small,but that was the first collage I have made.Oh,and one more thing.There isn`t any leaf there,if you are reffering to the one above the cat,it is a mutilated,torn-apart body of a chicken. The beak is somewhat visible,I should have made the photo larger :)

[Heidi]

I felt #3 was the most emotional. The portrait expression really grabs me, drawing me in to the other pieces, making me wonder how they are related.

[Isabel]

@spaceman I had tried to click on what I thought was a leaf, (yes above the cat) and couldn't. An interesting include..... thanks for answering me back, nice to have a discussion. hoping to see more.