Unwanted object removal.

July 30th, 2017
Kas
I have been looking all afternoon for an affordable unwanted object removal programme. I generally use Photos (Mac) for editing and spot removal - but it is not the best for some larger bits and pieces - buoys, telephone poles etc. I don't have PS - not expert enough with in-camera settings to begin to unravel PS yet, so looking for a mid-way editing tool in the meantime. Have found Inpaint and Movavi - but not sure if they are any good or just a waste of money. Any advice or suggestions would be greatly appreciated. Many thanks, Karen.
July 30th, 2017
I use FastStone for editing. Free to download with just a one-off donation. A fiver will do it.
July 30th, 2017
Kas
@quietpurplehaze Thanks Hazel - just had a look, and it is not compatible with MacBook. Only Windows.
July 30th, 2017
Kas, in picmonkey under the magic wand pic (2nd option down) scroll all the way down to the very bottom is the 'clone' option. This can be used to copy parts of photo to cover over what you don't want there, it works the same way as PS.
July 30th, 2017
Hi Kas
On the ones I've tested I found SnapHeal to be the most like Photoshops healing brush. The results are about the same. Its on the app store and quite cheap.
July 30th, 2017
Kas
@stephanies Thanks Stephanie. I had a look, and it seems I can only use Picmonkey after I've loaded the image onto 365 and then edit in Picmonkey. It seems to be a Windows platform rather than Mac - although I think there are third party extensions available, but not too sure about that.
@ianforbes Thanks Ian - I'll go and have a look.
July 30th, 2017
I piccy.com has a clone feature
July 30th, 2017
Hi Kas, Photoscape works with a Mac, theres a lot in the free version but you do need to pay for the bit with the clone tool in. Worth a look.
July 30th, 2017
Kas
@grammyn Thanks Katy. I'll go and look at that one too.
@markp Thanks Mark - interestingly, I downloaded that one earlier, and then noted the extra costs.
July 31st, 2017
@wag864 I got it a while ago with the clone tool free, its still on the old Mac.
When I got a new Mac I had to pay to get the clone tool, I did wonder if I could have copied the old version to the new one. Shame it's the clone tool you are after.
July 31st, 2017
Hi, I just downloaded snapheal as per Ian Forbes. I used it to clone out a spade on my image Biskit Basking, if you need an example
July 31st, 2017
Kas
@yorkshirekiwi @ianforbes I downloaded snapheal and it worked wonders! Used it on my latest image 'Listen! Can you hear the bagpipes'. I also managed to remove the rope that was tying the boat to the large rock in the foreground.
July 31st, 2017
@wag864 Hi Kas! I use iPiccy that has a good clone tool. It works both with Mac and Windows (I have tried both) and is quite effective. I used it to cancel a lamp and a wire in my Silouhettes against the sunset. I highly recommend it. It's FREE!
July 31st, 2017
@wag864 Kas, I keep my pictures in "Windows Live Photo Gallery" on my computer and you can download it for free.
It has a "retouch" tool that works really well for me when I want to clone out a light pole or get spots out of the sky, etc. It's really easy to use, too.
July 31st, 2017
@wag864 Glad it helped. Its the one I would use if i didn't have Photoshop.
August 1st, 2017
I use iPiccy's clone tool and Ribbet most of the time. I think they work really well and since it's on-line it seems to be compatible with everything.
August 1st, 2017
I have found Photoscape's Spot healing tool quite helpful although not as good on bigger areas. It works well on my Mac.
August 1st, 2017
Gimp photo editor
Open source and free.
Similar to photoshop.
It is awesome but has a steep learning curve if you want to do clever things like layers ...
https://www.gimp.org/
August 1st, 2017
@wag864 when you upload your image to 365 there is a box to select whether your picture is public or restricted. I can't quite remember the total wording but i think it won't then be seen by people on the site and you can edit it in pic monkey and resave it and then make it public.
August 1st, 2017
Kas
@caterina @mittens @olivetreeann @kiwinanna @phil_howcroft @jennywren Thank you for all your help and suggestions. I have downloaded a few of the options mentioned to see what does what. Jen, I'll have a look when I next upload to see what I need to do to work with Picmonkey. Huge thank you everyone!
August 4th, 2017
@phil_howcroft I'm glad I'm not the only Gimp user here.

Open Source!
August 4th, 2017
@stephomy I use GMP, Darktable and Rawtherapee depending upon what I am editing !!! Darktable appears to be my fav of the three :)
(I run Linux / Ubuntu...but I am not that geeky / techiie)

Write a Reply
Sign up for a free account or Sign in to post a comment.