Critique Please: Light and line... by northy

Critique Please: Light and line...

Lemme explain... a couple weeks ago when i was shooting this: http://365project.org/northy/365/2013-01-06 , i took a photo looking along the length of the walkway... only it was kind of boring... so i tried to convince one of my boys to go back there with me to be a model, but he copped out on me at the last minute... Anyhoo, i went back there this evening and since I was still without a model, i stood in for one... so yeah... that's me... I would have tried a different pose, but the wind picked up and it was making me exceedingly nervous to be 30 feet away from my camera ;0

I intend to go back WITH someone in tow... so I am mostly posting this for suggestions for improving the comp and basically making the most of the location...

Thank you... that's all... night night...
I think it a was worth it. This shot tells story and I love the flare
January 20th, 2013  
I did need someone there to make it a real picture. The stars in the sky light up the way beautifully!
January 20th, 2013  
great composition... I like the lighting/shadows and light flares.. nicely composed
January 20th, 2013  
very nice! love it! i'd be happy with the shot. :)
January 20th, 2013  
Given the narrowness of the scene and darkness all around, there is not much more you can do except if you had two models, one in the foreground up close on the left and then one where you are on the right so its balanced and adds depth. Maybe the models are smoking or something to add bit of light. But its cool as is too and love those star lights.
January 20th, 2013  
I think this is awesome!! Especially being a slefie.
Love the lines, shows and flares...the composition really draws you into the photo and creates a great atmosphere!
January 20th, 2013  
Great shot Northy, A few things that I would want to try... Very low PoV, like say a foot off the ground, might be cool. Also maybe moving the model a little closer to the camera but still under a light to try to catch a little more detail. Just some suggestions I think that the shot is Aces the way it is
January 20th, 2013  
@michaelelliott tx Michael... unlikely that my models would smoke ;p but yeah, if i could convince one of my boys to come out, i could prolly convince two (or three)... wonder if i could do something with lightsticks without it getting over the top...
January 20th, 2013  
@jsorensenart tx Jake! i did one edit cropped in so the, ahem, model was more the focal point... and then deleted it ;p yes - if i get a chance with some help i will definitely do some a bit more focussed on the human :)
January 20th, 2013  
Beautiful
January 20th, 2013  
TC
I loved the lighting and rich contrast!
January 20th, 2013  
Great light and line shot... My eye is taken through. Well done
January 20th, 2013  
This is incredible! :) I love the flare in the lights and you make the perfect stand in :) Great composition and brilliant shot!
January 20th, 2013  
Beautiful!! I love how sharp the light flares are.
January 20th, 2013  
I love it! Nicely done. In my mind, I then wonder, what would it look like cropped more to one side rather than centred? So there is more negative black to one side, say on the left.
January 20th, 2013  
a cool location and a great mood! Suggestions : Put the camera very low, it always adds drama to the shot. While you're at it, put the camera close to the right side of the walkway and forget trying to make the walkway symmetrical. Now as the camera is low & on the right, the vanishing point could be composed at around the interesction of lower & left third. Also, now there shouldn't be too much pure black on the right side, only on the left side of the frame which should make the contrast of darkness vs. light pretty effective. For the person there, I think the viewer needs to have some detail to lead the imagination to a certain direction. A briefcase would make me think some secret agent for example... maybe put the Indy hat on ? Just some thoughts, hope you'll get the shot you want !
January 20th, 2013  
You have found a great location to shoot! I feel really inspired by the comments. My thoughts were wondering in the same direction with Cassandra and Jani about the composition, and love the suggestions about adding some accessories to create a story.
January 20th, 2013  
Hmmmm, either shoot from dead centre, in that case go a little lower but not right on the floor, or from the far right or left. I quite like Jani's briefcase idea but without a person, or some other random object placed there, hmmmm, like an ironing board for example, just something that has no reason to be there. If it was a person, then, I dunno, sitting cross legged in the distance (a bit cliched), laying on the ground staring into space, foetal position etc.

Its a cool location, but I think it needs to be a kinda surreal shot. But I suck at staging shots so could just be talking crap. :)
January 20th, 2013  
Great shot - great location! How about shooting with the camera very low to the ground - you'll get a very different POV which you might like? : )
January 20th, 2013  
Sue
I can't give in comments, but very interesting reading the comments. I think it's a great shot but can see how from low on the left couple add to it .... I like the briefcase idea but also the random item suggestion. Great shot!
January 20th, 2013  
I agree with Lisa, but wouls go in closer to the shot, be nearer to the lights
January 20th, 2013  
I'd go with the shooting low as well, I like jase's idea of an ironing board or something there, but probably a little impractical.
I held up my hands to cut off some of the blackness on the sides... I think I would prefer it a little.
January 20th, 2013  
Love the location. It has great lines and the starburst lights are cool.
You've got some fab suggestions here. Love the ironing board one. :)
January 20th, 2013  
love this. very moody
January 20th, 2013  
@janim @jase_h you guys are brilliant awesome!!!

frigid blustery weather looming all week, so it may be a while before i can get back there... even if i could talk the kids into it, no way i could keep the camera steady on the tripod!

the ironing board sounds wonderfully random, btw... given the right approach, i bet i could convince my oldest to lug one up there ;p (and it would be easier than a TV, which somehow occurred to me after you mentioned the ironing board suggestion...

@ozziehoffy @houdiniem @monika64 tx!! i actually did try out a closer crop and i agree it makes for a more interesting composition... but just wasn't in the mood to post another selfie and also thought it would be better to show a more fulsome lay-of-the-land shot for requesting input... will definitely try tighter framing and lower pov when i go back...
January 20th, 2013  
@northy It's a great spot... I'm sure you'll go and shoot there again armed with some new ideas :)
January 20th, 2013  
I really love this. It's so dramatic. Love the location and the bursts are lovely.
January 20th, 2013  
What a great location! I totally agee with low pov. It would be fun seeing you blow around in the blizzard. ;) Right now it's whiteout conditions here.
January 20th, 2013  
are you kidding me?!? i was there, although not in the evening. and i would be nervous, too, if i was that far from my camera, especially if that stupid guy who rides his motorized bicycle comes by, you know the one who brazenly disobeys the sign that says "riders dismount bicycles when using walkway" but so coward as to cover his face. i laughed when he rounded the corner and he banged his knee, the jerk! where was i? oh, yeah, i was there this afternoon. i shoulda left a note for you. :-) i can be your model, whadja like me to do, climb as if i wanted to be roadkill? hehehe!
January 20th, 2013  
@summerfield there was no one there at 7am when i took the light trail shot two weeks ago... and last night at 8 there was one guy walking his bike and a couple out strolling and that was it... i figure for a night shoot it'll be pretty empty :) sure you can come be my model... no roadkill shots... bring shades and plan to look enignmatic ;p
January 20th, 2013  
sorry, i forgot about the photo. i like this, the stark emptiness of the walkway, the starbursts from the light and the silhoutte of the 'model'. i know you hate being on camera, but i like the suggestion of being closer, the ample amount of light on the head would be awesome if we see a more defined silhoutte, with smoke coming out. i have an idea for a low-key shot for you. i also need a model, partner doesn't cut it sometimes.
January 20th, 2013  
oh, and i like jase's @jase_h ironing board suggestion. that would be awesome!
January 20th, 2013  
@summerfield we should plan a meet up... actually, @russianblue and i already talked about one... problem is my schedule sucks and weekends are a huge unknown right now with kids sports...
January 20th, 2013  
@summerfield ok - you can carry the ironing board ;p
January 20th, 2013  
@northy - i like that! meet up, not carrying the i/b. :-P
January 20th, 2013  
Very nice night shot. I do like the way the lamps have gone all starry too. I perhaps wouldn't have so much black on the right hand side. I would chose one side to have the leading darkness and not both. Having said that, I do like it as it is.
January 20th, 2013  
Wow....I like this shot...but reading the suggestions, there's lots of good ideas to do different shots....I won't say improve because this is really well done.
January 20th, 2013  
wouldn´t change a thing about it! FAV! :)
January 20th, 2013  
I really like this!!! Nice and original!!! Very nicely composed!!!
January 20th, 2013  
My first thought was to have the lines leading to one side rather than the centre. Low POV also a good idea. Love the light flares and the exposure here.
January 20th, 2013  
I like the line and lighting of this ...... the starring of the lights is lovely :)
January 20th, 2013  
I think it's an excellent photograph, really don't have any feedback but "Well done" :)
January 20th, 2013  
@northy Whilst I know I am brilliant, it is always nice to have it confirmed :P
January 20th, 2013  
Wow, all kinds of awesome comments. I was thinking if the person was walking perpendicular to the camera, you would have a more distinct silhouette.
January 20th, 2013  
Beautiful lines and wonderful starbursts. Like it.
January 20th, 2013  
Love this b&w shot!!!!!!
January 20th, 2013  
i can't critic a genius ---this is superb !!--:)
January 20th, 2013  
Great job.......... nothing wrong in this one..
January 20th, 2013  
Line of flares works. Has a noir film feel
January 21st, 2013  
I think this is great! I love the stars, and the lone figure (you!) makes this a much more interesting shot than if you weren't there.
January 21st, 2013  
As I'm playing catch up...again!! I haven't time to read all the suggestions that have already been made so will just go on what I think and hope I'm not being repetitive for you. Firstly it looks awesome magnified. The star flares are brill and putting yourself into frame works really well as I think the scene needs a focal point like a figure. The only thing I might have done is to perhaps crop some of the lower half and have more 'sky' but as I'm no expert on these things please disregard any/all of what I've said. I wish I had half your talent lady ;o) xx
January 21st, 2013  
l agree with Michael's comments - great shot...more so for being a selfie!!
January 22nd, 2013  
I would take out the bottom fifth to bring the figure forward and the right quarter to move it to the right. I think you were keen on the vanishing point because you made it central - my suggestions might spoil that but you have to decide what's important about your shot. Brave of you to move so far from your camera!
January 24th, 2013  
I get the feeling the horizon is slightly tipping to the right?
And I would have brought the person (you, I guess) just a bit closer.
But otherwise I love the composition.
January 25th, 2013  
My critique is to fave this...but I can see the cropping might work with the figure close to the lower right corner.
January 25th, 2013  
Leave a Comment
Sign up for a free account or Sign in to post a comment.