@gigiflower I was using a tripod also and a 70-300 lens that I was given many years ago. I am going to take another shot tonight using the same settings that you used but I am pretty sure I know the answer. I think it will give a very clear (pardon the pun) example of the value of a good quality lens over a cheap and nasty one. See what happens tonight.
http://www.kenrockwell.com/nikon/70-200mm-ii.htm
It weighs a tonne.......but is just amazing. I get sore arms holding it!