Help me decide... please! by kwind

Help me decide... please!

I took these yesterday in preparation for next week's Father's day card. I can't decide which I like better and the kids have split the decision so I need additional opinions. Top or bottom??

**This was taken a day early and won't fit within the Fathers theme timeline but I thought I'd tag it anyhow.
Top
June 2nd, 2013  
De
Top.
June 2nd, 2013  
Top.
June 2nd, 2013  
Bottom
June 2nd, 2013  
Top
June 2nd, 2013  
Top
June 2nd, 2013  
Zam
for the composition I'll go with the top, but for the ''feeling'' is the one at the bottom. Good luck! :)
June 2nd, 2013  
Top
June 2nd, 2013  
Top - but both are great. What a lovely idea.
June 2nd, 2013  
To be honest, at first glance I thought the top was better balanced, but when I really looked at both pictures, the wording in the upper right corner of the bottom shot gives balance to the bottom shot..... but mainly, I find the legs too distracting in the top... I'm not seeing 2 children... I'm seeing one child with 2 heads and 4 legs. Maybe its a guy thing. ;)
June 2nd, 2013  
Both are fantastic, but if I had to choose, I would say top.
June 2nd, 2013  
Bottom (both super cute!)
June 2nd, 2013  
They are both awesome and super cute, but I definitely prefer the bottom one.
June 2nd, 2013  
both fantastic ~ I am sure he would be pleased to receive either ~ I prefer the bottom
June 2nd, 2013  
Top. They both look even more joyfull in there than at the bottom ( whichis also nice)!
June 2nd, 2013  
Top for me! A certain sweetness to it. And BTW love the idea and they are both wonderful. Which ever you choose it will be a big hit, I am sure!!
June 2nd, 2013  
top :) Both are great shots though!
June 2nd, 2013  
Top, they look like they're having more fun :)
June 2nd, 2013  
Both such fun and creative shots! I agree with Jeff's @jsw0109 observation about the legs in the top image. I find the position a little distracting, too. Although, I do love the processing and the kids' expressions of the top image. The bottom one is great. I like the tones and body positions. I might make the lettering just a bit larger on the bottom one. Whatever you chose, you will may this father very happy, I'm sure!
June 2nd, 2013  
Fav.top
June 2nd, 2013  
Lovely idea and execution. The bottom one gets my vote. Do let us know which one won out.
June 2nd, 2013  
I love both!!! that's a really hard decision!!
June 2nd, 2013  
A close thing but i think bottom but only for the reason that the message is clearer on that one ....both fab though & I'm sure he will be very happy with either!
June 2nd, 2013  
I love them both, but the top one is my favorite. I love the processing and your kids smiles!
June 2nd, 2013  
the top one is my fav! love them both !
June 2nd, 2013  
I love them both but I prefer the colour one.
June 2nd, 2013  
Awesome
June 2nd, 2013  
Nia
How about using both? The one you prefer or most agreed upon on the front cover and the other on on the back as a smaller image? Or make one as a print for office and one as the card. They are both wonderful!
June 2nd, 2013  
Whichever you use the message of love will be there!
June 2nd, 2013  
Hard choice. I'd say bottom, but I'm usually wrong. :)
June 2nd, 2013  
what a great idea! lovely!
June 2nd, 2013  
Colour one - lovely
June 2nd, 2013  
color!!!!! wonderful and cute
June 2nd, 2013  
Top. I love the crowdedness and the giggles. Might be interesting in color too, but I can't decide.
June 2nd, 2013  
Top! I love the composition better and the giggly faces!
June 2nd, 2013  
I love the top one with the sepia and the leg positions and the giggly kids. Wonderful, but they both are :o) xx
June 2nd, 2013  
I'm sure your husband would love them both. I love the top one because of their smiles!! Very sweet!!
June 2nd, 2013  
Can you process the bottom one vintage? I think it has the better balance, as the legs in the top photo tend to stand out more than the faces. But I like the look of the top one for its vintage feel.
June 2nd, 2013  
Both superb images Kim but top tighter crop and sepia works so well and expressions wonderful TOP :/)
June 2nd, 2013  
Both are wonderful. I prefer the bottom but would be nice in vintage.
June 2nd, 2013  
Ahh both are gorgeous!!! Top one edges it for me. For the expressions rather than the sepia.
June 2nd, 2013  
They are both excellent - I prefer the bottom due to the stunning light and lovely colors - it looks like a happier shot!
June 3rd, 2013  
Definitely TOP & lovely idea ! Fav :)
June 3rd, 2013  
The top is awesome...love the sepia. They are both beautiful.
June 3rd, 2013  
Cute! I hope you get this printed and framed for a Father's Day gift. I think your husband will love it!
June 3rd, 2013  
Top one, but they are both fun!
June 3rd, 2013  
Has to be the bottom one.
June 3rd, 2013  
Love both, but prefer the bottom one... love the colors, kids feel more natural. Can you use both - put one on a card and the other in a frame?
June 3rd, 2013  
Bottom. I like how their legs are in this one...I agree with Jeff. They are "astraddle" in the top one, and it is confusing. And, it says "Dad, We Love You" but I like the bottom , with them side by side and the more clear "We Love you Dad." The color one is more vibrant and has that "shot from down low" feel and more three dimensionality. (Is that a word?)
June 3rd, 2013  
You can read the print on their feet better in the colored version too.
June 3rd, 2013  
bottom- seems there's more clarity all the way around.
June 3rd, 2013  
Both are great, but between the two I prefer the bottom one.
June 3rd, 2013  
I like the bottom. He will LOVE either one.
June 3rd, 2013  
Both are awesome! I think I like the bottom one best. Great idea! I was trying to think of something similar, but just have one little one!
June 3rd, 2013  
love the top one :)
June 3rd, 2013  
@ashesand Look on Pinterest or google "father's day photo ideas" for inspiration. There's tons of ideas out there.
June 3rd, 2013  
@happysnap @bensonst I just couldn't decide so I'm going to use both. One for the cover and one for the inside.
June 3rd, 2013  
Very cute. I like the pretty colors in the bottom one.
June 3rd, 2013  
Why don't you make two cards, that way they can both give him the card with the photo they like.
June 3rd, 2013  
Love it!
June 3rd, 2013  
Perfect!!
June 3rd, 2013  
Sue
Both are fabulous ... I love the top.
June 3rd, 2013  
Both are great but I like the processing on the top better and the composition on the bottom better. I see you are going to use both. Great idea.
June 3rd, 2013  
Top...very cute!
June 3rd, 2013  
I love both. But i'll choose the top pic in colour.. i just love their smile there...and great idea too! A fav!
June 3rd, 2013  
How cool is this? real cool
you are so creative
June 3rd, 2013  
Love the comparison in years how fast they do grow
June 3rd, 2013  
Top. They are both really good. Very creative and fun.
June 3rd, 2013  
Amy
love them both but the bottom is the bomb
June 4th, 2013  
I'm no help because I love the composition of the top one and the colour of the bottom one.
June 4th, 2013  
Both, but my vote would be for the bottom one :)
June 4th, 2013  
Bottom! Both are full of joy, wonderful shot.
June 4th, 2013  
Bottom! But they are both amazing!
June 4th, 2013  
i really love both and to be honest they actually look amazing put together! Like you posted here!
June 4th, 2013  
love them both but prefer bottom............great idea!
June 4th, 2013  
Both photos are perfect, but I prefer the bottom one! Wonderful idea!
June 4th, 2013  
...and forgot to fav this :)
June 4th, 2013  
Very creative ideas! I think I prefer the top one.
June 4th, 2013  
Top :) Very cute!
June 4th, 2013  
Sorry - late to the party on this. I love the giggles in the top one but think that making both is a good call! :)
June 4th, 2013  
What a lovely idea - I can't choose between them sorry!! Your children look so wonderfully happy in the top shot, but I love the colours of the bottom!!!! Can you not make a double-sided card, with a picture on each side? LOL : )
June 4th, 2013  
I like both but would go for the bottom, i prefer the balance, but as there are 2 children couldn't they do one each! Hard decision!
June 5th, 2013  
Wonderful. I like them both. I would do them both too! (bottom if I have to choose one)
June 5th, 2013  
I think the top one because you are both laughing all out.
June 5th, 2013  
amazing idea and wonderful shot :)
June 5th, 2013  
Bottom, but as a dad, I would very happily receive either!!!
June 5th, 2013  
Meg
Love the bottom one!
June 6th, 2013  
Bottom is favorite! Great shots of both tho.
June 6th, 2013  
both of them are very beautiful! but I prefer the bottom one! so warm and lovely colors!
June 6th, 2013  
I like the top one - so creative! He'll love it!
June 6th, 2013  
TC
Their expressions and the POV in the top one are my choice. I like the color photo but find your daughter's feet looking odd at this angle (crossed over) ...how did the top one look in color??? Both so very creative...I might need to borrow your idea...that is if my kids would be willing to do something like this! :)
June 6th, 2013  
very cute, I can imagine how they laught writing under their feet !! ;)
June 7th, 2013  
They're both great!
June 7th, 2013  
I like the black and white. At first I trhought it was an old photo and a new photo!
June 8th, 2013  
I didn't realize we were supposed to vote. If it isn't too late I like the color version a bit more!
June 8th, 2013  
What a wonderful idea for father´s day card! I liked the b&w better, so which one did you choose?
June 8th, 2013  
Great shots! You couldn't have gone wrong either way!!!
June 9th, 2013  
Oh my gawsh these r BOTH adorable!!!
June 9th, 2013  
Both of them are super cute. Love the processing, softness and idea. Fav!
June 9th, 2013  
So sweet!
June 10th, 2013  
Leave a Comment
Sign up for a free account or Sign in to post a comment.