Help me Decide, Please!

One of these is going to be a card for my son's baseball coach at the end of the season. I saw the word 'Coach' made of baseball items on Pinterest and decided to tweak the concept by spelling 'Thank you' instead. I can't decide if I like the colour or B&W version better. What do you think??

[julia]

Both look fantastic but I do like the colour one... What a neat thing to do.. would of taken a bit of planning..

[Jay Butterfield]

Color definitely

[Martina]

Color!!! The card is fantastic!

[Gena Pegg]

WOWzie...love them both but the color has just the right amount of "punch"! Awesome!

[JoMo]

LOVE this! Colour one has more impact. (I'm stealing this idea btw!)

[Katrina]

Colour ☺

[Dyan Stevens]

Color! What a wonderful idea.

[Alison]

I prefer the ccolour version, it stands out more than the BW (I think)
You are so good at these !

[Francesca Ciarrocchi]

They are both wonderful but the coloured one is my favourite! Really cool!

[Annie D]

I prefer the colour - what a great idea - looks really good Kim

[Newbank Lass]

On here colour but I have feeling the b and w may look really fab in greater resolution. Do you think it has lost some of its clarity? Love the idea

[Iris]

color. Great card!!

[Beryl Lloyd]

I prefer the colour version ! -- great idea !

[Brigette]

i love B&W.. but no contest! definitely colour for this

[Graeme Stevens]

I can't believe that I'm about to say this, but for this it has to be the colour one

[Clare Gadsby]

Clever. I'd go colour here

[Margo]

Definately the coloured one!!

[Dianne]

Brilliant - fav for being so creative and clever! The coloured one for me.

[Denise Wood]

Colour one too :)

[Ali P]

I also prefer the coloured one!

[HEW]

Coloured one! Very creative.

[Kate Macdonald]

Colour for me!

[alia_801]

Nicely done! I like the colour one too :)

[Babs]

They are both fabulous, but definitely the colour one for the card.

[Tracy]

They look great, and the color version!

[e.gad]

How fun and personal. I prefer the color version.

[Lin]

First of all, this is so awesome! Very creative! Secondly, I think the words show up best in black and white, but the photos show best in color (how's that for not being helpful?) Whichever you decide, this is a winning idea and will be much appreciated, I'm sure!

[Tabbycat]

Def colour! Cool concept..

[Kathy A]

Definitely colour

[gloria jones]

Fabulous shot, clever idea...love the color version

[Suse♡]

The colored one for me. Very cool concept too!

[Rosie Kerr]

What a great concept to thank your son's coach for the season! For me, I like the color. It brings some of the "fun" of baseball into the idea. Both are really great, though. Coach is going to love it!

[Daryl O'Hare]

Color. Agree with @rosiekerr

[mittens (Marilyn)]

They are both great, but I think I like the colored one better. I think it made the letters stand out better.

[vstap]

Color for me!

[Jeff in VT, USA]

Cool idea. Color!

[ChristineL]

For me, the items stand out better on the colour version, great idea!

[Margaret Brown]

What a great idea! Lovely capture, and it would have to be the colour for me

[MaryElizR]

I like them both but the color version is really great!

[Lady Magpie (Heather)]

Great idea and wonderful capture, it has to be the coloured one for me.

[sarah]

Fantastic idea & a great set of images!

[Bill Fenske]

Black and white; it'll go with any room colour.

[carol white]

Great images, think the b/w is more effective

[bkb in the city]

Prefer the b/w

[Karen Mitchell]

seriously... I would find that idea the day after the end of baseball season and then save it to forget each season again! Brilliant, either one, but the colour might suit the situation more this time.

[Jane Pittenger]

black and white for sure

[Jocasta]

I like them both - really can't decide. Fantastic idea.

[Jocasta]

ps FAV

[Anja]

Lovely capture, what a great idea! I prefer the color version.

[Margaret Obey]

Super idea. I like both but prefer the colour one.

[Lynda McG]

The colourful one - nice colours and creativity!

[Lesley Chisholm]

I'd have to agree colour, althought they both look great. Fab idea, I'm sure he'll love it.

[Joan Robillard]

The color one and he will love either.

[Janet B.]

What a fantastic idea! I love both images, but the color is my favorite. Such a thoughtful project that will surely be a hit!

[Milanie]

Absolutely fantastic idea - the consensus seems to be color - I love them both. Fabulous creativity.

[Nicole Campbell]

Great idea - I like the colour version

[Danette Thompson]

Such a fabulous idea!

[Shy Abel]

that is soooooo cool! love love love it

[Louise & Ken]

This is wonderful! The coach with be totally knocked out by such a wonderful gesture! Definitely, in my book the colour one! It's fun and cheery!

[Susan Klassen]

The colour version has more pop!

[Frank Hymus]

I hope you decided on the color. I think it much more interesting.

[Issi Bannerman]

Brilliant. I bet coach will be delighted to receive this!

[Pyrrhula]

Color thakes more attention. So I go for the collored one.

[Barb Newcomb]

Colour definitely!

[Brooke Lindsay]

I like the color. The black and white seems too "high concept" for a thank you card for someone who works with kids! Great artwork though!

[Lisa Stein]

What a great idea! Love it. Definitely the color one!

[Jerome]

Wonderful idea! Wonderful composition! Both are delicious! Fav

[Tricia Przybylowicz]

This is fantastic. You could sell these for sure. Great idea and well executed!

[Simply Amanda]

So super. Leaning toward color but really torn. What did you decide on? Great idea!

[KWind]

@alophoto I'm not giving it out for a while so I have time to decide but I'm pretty sure I'll go with the colour version.

[Nina Ganci]

wonderful creative idea. for the coach I would go colour. Maybe also do it a little larger and frame it for him.

[Leslie]

Color was a great choice . You are so creative and I'm sure the coach will treasure the card.