Collaboration?

Ray ( @ray_milsted ) wondered what my post of the Viking woodcarver would look like in B&W. Such things are not my forte, so I asked my resident expert for aid.

Ian got quite carried away in Picassa and I thought the results would make an interesting collage to post.

Ian, ever efficient, noted what he had done:

B&W
Sepia
Vignette & 1960’s
Pencil sketch

I hope you enjoy the results of his "playing". Which result do you like, and why?

Katharine

[Judith Johnson]

Nicely done - I love the pencil sketch one!

[Padlock]

love the bottom right.

[Graham Thresher]

Super shots.

[Molly]

I agree that the image in the bottom right looks particularly appropriate for this subject matter - but all of them are good.

[Robert Smith]

I like the way you've done this. Reenactments are a wonderful sort of cross between theatre, living history and experimental archaeology, Looks like great fun.

[Pyrrhula]

The pencil one fits the best to the subject. as no of the other pic.`s can be made in that time. Great Picasa play

[Lynne Hart]

Ooh i think i prefer the sepia, adds age to the shot. Nice way to show off these 4 effects, good collage.

[Kim Crisp]

Interesting comparison, I really like the pencil drawn effect for this shot.

[gloria jones]

Well done...I really like this photo and the collage of processing is cool.

[Ivan]

Like them all! Creative.

[essiesue]

Great collage and the pencil sketch is outstanding. Interesting contrasts. fav

[bruni]

I really like the pencil sketch. Ian, picture number 2 and 3 are very similar. all in all I like the collage. fav.

[bkb in the city]

Very cool

[Julia]

Fun edit

[Fisher Family]

@busylady @padlock @thresheg @thresheg @dolphin @rob24 @pyrrhula @lhart @kimcrisp @seattlite @ivan @essiesue @bruni @bkbinthecity @juliac

Thank you all for your comments. I like to see the different effects Ian shows me and it seems a waste not to use them. I have to say that the pencil sketch is my favourite. Katharine