On the day: b&w or colour? by quietpurplehaze

On the day: b&w or colour?

In addition to being responsible for food and wine on our anniversary day, Neil was the 'official' photographer.

http://365project.org/quietpurplehaze/365/2015-08-23

Any thoughts, comments, constructive criticism welcome!
Sam
Given I'm addicted to B&W at the moment, I'm voting for this one! I feel this is a softer photo, more realistic! Maybe the colour is too harsh/bright for my eyes??
August 23rd, 2015  
I must say i like this version better. Happy anniversary....and love those earrings!!
August 23rd, 2015  
I completely agree with Sam
August 23rd, 2015  
Bep
B&W. Seems more natural, I think.
August 23rd, 2015  
@Cherrill

Made by our daughter,Clare, who works as a silversmith - silver and amethyst, for my birthday. I was lucky to receive a surprise anniversary gift commissioned by Ray from Clare - busy photographing it right now!
August 23rd, 2015  
I like this one best! It seems to capture lots of personality. You are both looking good! Happy anniversary!!!
August 23rd, 2015  
Difficult choice. I like them both and can't decide.
August 23rd, 2015  
Happy Anniversary! and I think this is a lovely photo of you both
August 23rd, 2015  
Does your daughter have a website?

August 23rd, 2015  
Happy Anniversary. this is a lovely shot of you both and a Fav
August 23rd, 2015  
Happy Anniversary and they are both great but I think I slightly prefer the B&W version
August 23rd, 2015  
Happy Anniversary to you both and what a fabulous portrait !!
August 23rd, 2015  
I'm a big fan of B/W photos. Love this one of the two of you. Happy Anniversary.
August 23rd, 2015  
pam
this really is a beautiful portrait-happy anniversary
August 23rd, 2015  
I like the B/W portrait. Happy anniversary.
August 23rd, 2015  
Great b&w portrait shot...Happy Anniversary.
August 23rd, 2015  
August 23rd, 2015  
Oh yes, her things are beautiful! I shall seriously contemplate a pair of earrings. Please pass on how much I like her work.
August 23rd, 2015  
@Cherrill

Thank you, I certainly will.
August 23rd, 2015  
TR
Happy Anniversary! I am a B&W kind of guy. Like how both of you are looking at the camera.
August 23rd, 2015  
@trm

Thanks - think we are both looking at our son behind the camera - and I was giving him instructions between shots!!!
August 23rd, 2015  
TR
@quietpurplehaze -and I was giving him instructions between shots!!! spoken from the heart of a mother. Too funny, I am blessed to still have my mom giving me advise on all things that matter.
August 23rd, 2015  
@trm

You made me smile and I'm glad you still have your mom!
August 23rd, 2015  
Lovely Anniversary capture of you both.
August 23rd, 2015  
Enjoy your anniversary! Lovely capture!
August 23rd, 2015  
Love this black and white! Happy Anniversary!
August 23rd, 2015  
i like the mono best hazel, not because it is mono, but because the colour is struggling a tad with the indoor lighting.

good eye detail and a nice vignette
August 23rd, 2015  
Happy Anniversary! Hard choice but I think I prefer this one.
August 24th, 2015  
Awesome portrait. Both are fantastic and a matter of personal choice.
August 24th, 2015  
@phil_howcroft

That's what I thought only I was going to say that the colour is a bit 'muddy'! I don't like, and hardly ever use, flash, and the plan was to take the photo in daylight but by the time we had got through duck, wine, pudding, the light had gone!!
August 24th, 2015  
@quietpurplehaze don't rule out flash hazel. It can work to your advantage, especially when you have people agaiist bright backgrounds (outside) ...the fill in flash will compensate for the overexposure you would otherwise get
August 24th, 2015  
@phil_howcroft

I used it once when taking a shot of folk who were against the sunset with their backs to the sea and it worked v well. I think I ought to study the flash on this Sony a6000 to see what it can do. But I'm still learning so much about the camera. (What I mainly learnt at the bird reserve at the weekend was that my 55-200 mm long zoom is not up to that type of bird photography!) I'm always happy to get these bits of advice from you, thank you so much.
August 24th, 2015  
@quietpurplehaze my pleasure hazel :-)
August 24th, 2015  
Thank you for your generous response to my 'ask' for preferences on our anniversary photo. It came out pretty even: 18 for b&w and 15 for colour - your reasons were interesting. I was a bit worried about Louise & Ken's suggestion of sepia as I thought we should look really ancient but I tried it and it was surprisingly good! Like some of you, I'm still a tad indecisive - I mean we had b&w for the wedding pics but a colour 45th anniversary pic would be nice! If it stops teeming with rain today, I'll ask Neil to take some 'D-Day + 2' shots outside as the light was a bit difficult indoors for the colour.

@rosiekind @thistle @timewalker @berghies @seattlite @nitrogene @linnypinny @phil_howcroft @fntngrma @gigiflower @Cherrill @denisef58 @trm @nana2r @lindamp5
August 24th, 2015  
A very happy couple, congratulations on your anniversary
August 24th, 2015  
Leave a Comment
Sign up for a free account or Sign in to post a comment.