Beautiful especially viewed on black , but I am in a bit of a quandary !! ( a woman's prerogative !! ) Both have merits ! but I love this one for its clarity ,
Hmm. Difficult. I like the light around the vase and flowers, just not on the vase like it was in the first photo. In my opinion, the vase colors aren't the same tone as the rest of the photo. There's sort of a halo around it making it a bit distracting.